Chateau des Grotteaux. Photo courtesy of “Reminiscences: A Glimpse of Old East Dallas.”
Remember when we wrote about the historic Lakewood castle on Gaston Avenue going to auction in September? Turns out there’s more to that story now.
Chateau des Grotteaux, the previous home of former Dallas mayor R. L. Thornton, was not given to the winner of the auction, despite an alleged contract agreeing to the sale. Now, that bidder — Jeff Hunter of Arizona — is suing the seller, Chateau Des Grotteaux LLC, according to The Dallas Morning News. Hunter allegedly placed the winning bid of $2.55 million and paid a $306,000 deposit. The sale was supposed to close Oct. 30 but didn’t.
“The contract at issue arose from a third-party auction process about which the company has raised serious concerns,” Chateau Des Grotteaux LLC attorney Audrey Bean told The Dallas Morning News. “That contract also expressly limits the remedies available to the buyer.”
On Oct. 7, George Smith, who manages Chateau Des Grotteaux LLC with Ellen Smith, allegedly told Hunter that he had proceeded to “freeze the transfer” and refund Hunter’s money for a “three-way mutual release,” where all parties would keep their original assets, according to The Dallas Morning News. When Hunter’s lawyers and Concierge Auctions asked for confirmation of the closing date, the seller refused and allegedly told the buyer, “There is a 0% chance you are buying this house for $2.5 million.”
The house was previously listed for $5.8 million, and bids were expected to start between $2 million and $3 million.
Smith also allegedly took issue with the auction process, calling it “corrupted,” claiming there were false bids and that he and the seller had been deceived by Concierge Auctions. according to The Dallas Morning News. Concierge is denying these accusations.
“Concierge solidified five qualified bidders, and the highest bidder won,” a spokesperson said to The Dallas Morning News. “The seller’s allegations of wrongdoing are manufactured and unfounded. The seller cannot disregard an auction result simply because he changed his mind.”
Hunter is apparently still open to buying the house, but if not, he wants to receive contract breach damages, according to The Dallas Morning News.
